About three weeks ago, I
wrote
[A]bout this time last month, I had finished working on and recording a
new song. I felt that I was out of ideas and that I'd never write another
song (this happens quite frequently). After finishing "Blind as a bat", I felt this emptiness again for a few
days but I knew that at some stage a new song would come. I was busy at the
beginning of the week with meetings, but on Tuesday evening I managed to
find some time to sit at the piano, and almost by magic a new tune appeared,
that I recorded onto my mobile phone. I had decided in advance that I wanted
a simple song in a minor key, to act as a contrast to some of the more
complicated material that I have been writing lately, and this new tune did
not disappoint.
In contrast to most of my songs, this one is almost completely diatonic: in
the key of A minor, the chords are Am G | F | F Em | D | F | C | Dm | E | Am
G | F | F Em | D | F | C | Dm | G | Dm | G G# dim. The only chromatic chord
is the D in bars 4 and 12; the G# diminished chord at the end can be seen as E7
without the root, that leads seamlessly to the A minor chord. I was pleased
by the fact that the 'chord rate' was not one chord per bar; there are bars
with two chords and there is a chord that is held for one and a half bars.
The song actually is very slow (66 bpm), leading me to suspect that each
half bar is really a bar, meaning that the tempo would become 132 bpm. Due
to this slow tempo, this simple song lasts over four minutes.
It wasn't until Thursday evening that I had the chance to transcribe the
tune into the MIDI sequencer; apart from the tune itself and staccato
chords, I added an extremely simple bass part and an arpeggiated part for a
Rhodes piano. On Friday morning I finished my programming duties early and
so was able to devote a few hours in developing the piece. The staccato
chords were thrown out and the Rhodes part became the major accompaniment. I
developed the bass part in the second verse, then added a few more parts.
The biggest problem was deciding on which instrument was going to play the
solo: originally I wanted a French horn, but this sounded too
synthesizer-like. I tried a variety of instruments and it wasn't until this
evening that I settled on a piano.
Originally I had no ideas for words, but as I was reading Sally Rooney's
"Normal people" (which we saw dramatised a few months ago), a few
sentences jumped out at me: For a few seconds they just stood there in stillness, his arms around
her, his breath on her ear. Most people go through their whole lives,
Marianne thought, without ever really feeling that close with anyone (in the April 2011 chapter). I thought that I could write something
based on this: it's free verse with no real rhymes. The tune and the free
verse made the phrasing slightly awkward.
This is the second time that I am reading the book; I think that the first
time around I got bored towards the end and never finished reading it, a
rare event. The same thing happened with the tv series which became less and
less interesting as it progressed.
I realised early on that A minor was too low a key for me to sing (the tune
runs from G below middle C upto A above middle C); shifting it up to B minor
seemed on paper to be sufficient but this was still too low for me to sing
comfortably, so in the end I transposed the song once again to C#
minor.
The vagaries of the phrasing made singing the song quite difficult, even
though I had a comfortable key, and I ended up creating a composite vocal
track of three different takes (basically each verse comes from a different
take). I thought that this was hard enough, but mixing the track, or more
accurately, obtaining the vocal sound that I wanted, required many different
attempts until I found the settings that were not too bassy and were clear.
Tomorrow I'll probably decide to change the equalisation settings once
again.
Additional comments from a few days later: I'm going to rerecord the vocals
as they should be more syncopated. Until I get the chance to do this
(probably Friday or Saturday), I can also get more familiar with the tune,
meaning that I'll sing it better. Certain lines should have been syncopated
which again would improve the quality of the vocals. I've also changed a few
lines in the words and I am mentally debating whether I should change the
short instrumental link between the first two verses.